Simon Cowell comments on Carrie Underwood

are you kidding me....carrie underwood is a million bajillion times better than bo bice i cant even belive he was in the final two he was horrible!!!! Carrie is and always will be the best american idol ever

i *heart* CARRIE MARIE UNDERWOOD!33

carrie is incredible, simon got this one right but i could have predicted that she would be huge after hearing that audition - and no she has had no surgery she has just dropped down in size which she didn't have to do cause she looked great anyway.

I'm glad u entered this...lol!

she didn't have any surgery... she lost weight lol she was a size 6 starting the show now shes a size 4

he is so accurate its scary...boo!

simon really is good. it makes me happy to know he likes carrie.he DOES know quality.

Simon is brilliance embodied. Love that man. Question, has Carrie had plastic surgery? She looks different now. I mean, I know AI contestants that are going somewhere always undergo pretty huge makeovers but she looks like she's had rhinoplasty or something.

Simon may be curt (there is NO room for coddling in this business) and IF he says "You'll be a star, YOU'LL be a star!! He knows his sh*t!!

he is my favorite american idol judge of all time